What do the Jews expectation of their Messiah?
Here is a clear and accurate summary of what many Jews in the Second Temple period expected of the Messiah, based on history, Scripture, and Jewish writings — no web search needed.
What were the Jews expecting of their Messiah in Jesus’ time?
In the time of Jesus, most Jews held a common expectation shaped by the Old Testament, by oppression under foreign nations, and by their religious teachers.
1. A political and military deliverer
They expected a Messiah who would:
- Defeat Israel’s enemies (especially Rome)
- Restore national sovereignty
- Re-establish the throne of David as a political kingdom (2 Samuel 7:12–16; Psalm 2)
- Bring peace through military victory (Isaiah 11:1–5 interpreted militaristically)
To them, the Messiah was a warrior-king, similar to David.
2. A restorer of Israel’s national glory
Many Jews believed the Messiah would:
- Gather all scattered Jews back to Israel (Isaiah 11:12)
- Restore the temple’s glory (Haggai 2:7–9)
- Bring Israel to a position of world prominence among nations
They saw the Messiah as a national savior, not a universal savior.
3. A purifier who would cleanse Israel
Especially the Pharisees expected the Messiah to:
- Purify the land from Gentile influence
- Purify worship and enforce Torah
- Restore righteousness by cleansing Israel of sinners
This is why they were offended that Jesus ate with tax collectors and sinners:
A true Messiah would separate from sinners, not welcome them.
4. A miracle-working prophet like Moses
Some expected:
- A prophet “like Moses” (Deuteronomy 18:15)
- A leader who would do public signs such as providing supernatural food (like manna)
This is why, after feeding the 5,000, the people wanted to make Jesus king by force.
5. A Messiah who rewards the faithful
Some believed the Messiah would:
- Reward the righteous (people like the Pharisees)
- Punish the wicked (Romans, Gentiles, and “sinners”)
This is why Jesus’ message of grace offended them.
They expected the Messiah to show favor to the holy, not mercy to the broken.
But Jesus didn’t fit their expectations.
Instead of:
- military power → Jesus came with gentleness
- national salvation → He offered spiritual salvation
- judgement of sinners → He ate with sinners
- overthrowing Rome → He conquered sin and death
- restoring political Israel → He brought the Kingdom of God, which is spiritual and worldwide
This explains why Jesus told the parable of the prodigal son.
The parable corrects wrong Jewish expectations about God and the Messiah:
1. God is not like the Pharisees thought.
They saw God as:
- strict
- conditional
- favoring the righteous
- withholding acceptance until repentance is proven
But Jesus revealed:
- A Father who runs to the sinner
- A love that restores first, then transforms
- A grace that goes out to both sons
2. The older son represents the Jews’ wrong expectation of the Messiah.
He believed:
- the father values obedience more than relationship
- sinners should be punished, not welcomed
- righteousness earns rewards
- grace should be limited
This was the common belief of many Jews about the Messiah.
3. Jesus uses the story to correct the entire national mindset.
He was saying:
“Your understanding of God is incomplete.
The Father is more gracious than you ever imagined.”
Summary: The Jews expected a Messiah who was:
- A political deliverer
- A military king
- A national restorer
- A purifier enforcing Torah
- A rewarder of the righteous and punisher of sinners
But Jesus revealed the Messiah to be:
- The Savior of sinners
- The revelation of the Father’s heart
- The One who restores by grace, not by law
- The true Son who brings us home
If you want, I can also explain:
• Why the Jews missed their Messiah
• How Jesus fulfilled the Messiah prophecies differently than expected
• How the prodigal parable confronts Jewish messianic expectations directly
Would you like that?
Is the jewish expecting a political or spiritual messiah?
A clear and simple answer:
Most Jewish people today are expecting a political Messiah, not a spiritual one.
But some streams expect a mix of both.
Let’s break it down clearly and accurately.
⭐ 1. Mainstream Judaism expects a political, human Messiah
Traditional Judaism teaches:
✔ The Messiah will be a human descendant of David, not divine
✔ He will be a political and military leader
✔ He will restore Israel's sovereignty
✔ He will bring world peace
✔ He will rebuild the Temple in Jerusalem
✔ He will gather all Jews back to Israel
This is taught in:
- Orthodox Judaism
- Conservative Judaism
- Many in Reform Judaism (although with spiritual interpretations)
This Messiah is not expected to die for sins or rise again.
⭐ 2. They Do NOT expect a suffering or spiritual Messiah (in general)
Most Jewish teaching today does not accept:
- A divine Son of God
- A Messiah who forgives sins
- A Messiah who dies and resurrects
- A Messiah who brings spiritual salvation first
They see salvation mainly as:
- National
- Physical
- Political
- Earthly
This is exactly why Jesus was rejected by many in His time — they expected a military king.
⭐ 3. Some Jews expect TWO Messiahs
In some Jewish traditions (especially older rabbinic writings):
1️⃣ Messiah ben Joseph — a suffering or dying messiah
2️⃣ Messiah ben David — the conquering king
They believe the suffering one prepares the way for the king.
This is not mainstream, but it is real in many rabbinic texts.
Christians understand this as:
- Jesus' first coming — the suffering Messiah
- Jesus' second coming — the conquering King
⭐ 4. Modern Israeli society is mixed
Today in Israel:
🇮🇱 Many secular Jews
Do not expect a messiah at all.
🇮🇱 Some expect a “symbolic” or “spiritual” age of peace
Not a literal person.
🇮🇱 Orthodox and ultra-Orthodox Jews
Expect a literal political messiah, a powerful leader who will guide Israel.
These are the groups most active in preparing for the Third Temple.
⭐ 5. Therefore, the current Jewish expectation is mostly political
- A leader who brings peace
- A man who strengthens Israel
- Someone who protects them from enemies
- A figure who allows or initiates the Third Temple
This expectation actually aligns closely with the coming Antichrist’s role, which is why many prophecy teachers believe the Antichrist will appear as a false messiah to Israel.
⭐ Short summary
Judaism today expects a political, national, earthly Messiah — not a divine spiritual Savior.
If you want, I can explain:
📌 Why the Jews missed Jesus as Messiah
📌 What rabbis say the Messiah must do
📌 How the Jewish expectation sets the stage for end-time events
Just let me know!
Here is a clear and complete explanation of why the Jewish people missed Jesus as Messiah, what the rabbis expected, and how this sets the stage for end-time prophecy — in a simple and accurate way.
⭐ 1. Why Many Jews Missed Jesus as the Messiah
✔ Reason 1 — They expected a political liberator
In Jesus’ time, Israel was under Roman occupation.
The Jews were expecting someone who would:
- overthrow Rome
- restore the kingdom of David
- bring national independence
- rule from Jerusalem
But Jesus came:
- riding a donkey, not a war horse
- preaching forgiveness
- teaching love for enemies
- calling for repentance
- speaking of a spiritual kingdom
So they could not accept Him as Messiah because He did not fit their nationalistic expectations.
✔ Reason 2 — They did not expect the Messiah to suffer
Although Isaiah 53 clearly describes a suffering Messiah, many Jews interpreted it as:
- referring to Israel
- a metaphor
- a righteous remnant
They did not expect the Messiah to:
- be rejected
- die
- be crucified
- be raised from the dead
So when Jesus suffered, they said,
“He cannot be the Messiah — the Messiah conquers, he doesn’t suffer.”
✔ Reason 3 — They expected signs of worldly power, not humility
Jesus came humble and meek.
They expected the Messiah to come in glory and strength.
They did not realize there are two comings:
1️⃣ First coming — suffering savior
2️⃣ Second coming — conquering King
Because they didn’t divide the prophecies properly, the picture confused them.
⭐ 2. What Rabbis Teach the Messiah Must Do
Rabbinic Judaism teaches the Messiah will:
✔ Rebuild the Third Temple
(From Ezekiel and other rabbinic writings)
✔ Bring world peace
(Isaiah 2)
✔ Restore the kingdom of David
(Ezekiel 37)
✔ Gather all Jews back to Israel
(Isaiah 11)
✔ Defeat Israel’s enemies
(Various prophets)
✔ Establish an earthly political government
These are all the second coming prophecies Christians believe Jesus will fulfill in the future — but Jews expect one messianic coming, not two.
⭐ 3. How This Creates the Perfect Setup for the End Times
✔ Jews expect a political world leader
Revelation shows the Antichrist will be exactly that.
✔ Jews expect protection from enemies
Antichrist will offer a 7-year covenant of peace and security (Daniel 9:27).
✔ Jews expect the Third Temple
Antichrist will allow its building, then later desecrate it.
✔ Jews are looking for national salvation
Not spiritual salvation from sin — this makes them vulnerable to deception.
✔ Many are preparing Temple instruments and priesthood today
This increases the readiness for a political messiah figure.
⭐ 4. Summary — Why This Matters Prophetically
Everything the Jewish people expect in a political Messiah is exactly what:
- the Bible describes the Antichrist will pretend to be
- and what Jesus will ultimately fulfill at His second coming
This is why Jesus said:
“I have come in My Father’s name, and you do not receive Me;
if another comes in his own name, him you will receive.”
— John 5:43
This points to a future leader who Israel will accept — the false messiah.
⭐ If you want, I can explain:
📌 What Jesus will do at His Second Coming
📌 What the Antichrist will do in Israel step-by-step
📌 Why the Jewish longing for the Third Temple matters
📌 How Daniel, Revelation, and Matthew 24 fit together
Just tell me which one you want next.
How the jews interpret Daniel's prophecies, the tribulation and the coming of the Messiah?
Here is a clear, accurate, and easy-to-understand explanation of how Jewish (rabbinic) interpretation views Daniel’s prophecies, the tribulation, and the Messiah.
This is very different from Christian end-time understanding.
I will break it into 3 parts:
1️⃣ How Jews interpret Daniel’s prophecies
2️⃣ How Jews interpret tribulation / end-times trouble (Chevlei Mashiach)
3️⃣ How Jews interpret the coming of the Messiah
⭐ 1. How Jews Interpret Daniel’s Prophecies
✅ 1. Daniels 70 weeks (Daniel 9) — Jews do NOT interpret this as the 7-year tribulation
- Most rabbis avoid giving a strict timeline from Daniel 9 because the dates do not fit easily with Jewish history.
- They do not interpret the “70 weeks” as “490 years” leading to Jesus.
- Many rabbinic commentators connect Daniel 9 to:
- the return from Babylonian exile
- the rebuilding of the second Temple
- a historical figure like Antiochus or a later oppressor
Jewish commentary does not see Daniel 9:27 as a future Antichrist or covenant.
❗Rabbinic Judaism is very cautious with Daniel
Historically, the rabbis discouraged deep study of Daniel because:
- too many Jews used Daniel’s numbers to predict the Messiah
- this caused failed expectations and uprisings
- this brought persecution on the Jewish people
So today, Jewish scholars rarely teach Daniel as a future prophecy book.
⭐ 2. How Jews Interpret “Tribulation” (Chevlei Mashiach)
In Judaism, the end-time trouble is called:
חבלי משיח — Chevlei Mashiach
“The Birth Pangs of the Messiah”
This idea comes from the Talmud and prophetic books.
What they expect:
✔ A period of worldwide instability
- wars
- economic distress
- moral confusion
- nations rising against each other
✔ Intense persecution of the Jewish people
Many rabbis teach Israel will suffer greatly before Messiah comes.
✔ Rise of a global enemy (like Gog of Ezekiel 38–39)
Jews interpret “Gog and Magog” as:
- a final war
- a coalition of nations attacking Israel
- stopped by God Himself
✔ A time of suffering compared to birth pains
Not a structured 7-year tribulation like Christian teaching.
❌ They do NOT believe in:
- a rapture
- an Antichrist making a covenant
- a 7-year tribulation
- a mid-point abomination in a third Temple (at least not with the same Christian meaning)
⭐ 3. How Jews Interpret the Coming of the Messiah
Modern Judaism expects a human, political Messiah, not a divine one.
⭐ The Jewish Messiah (Mashiach ben David) will:
✔ Be a human king, descendant of David
Not the Son of God, not divine.
✔ Restore political independence
He will:
- defeat Israel’s enemies
- bring national safety
- establish Israel as the spiritual center of the world
✔ Rebuild the Third Temple
This is a major expectation.
Orthodox Jews believe Messiah will:
- oversee Temple construction
- restore sacrifices
- restore the priesthood
✔ Bring peace to Israel and the world
This includes:
- world peace
- justice
- end of war
✔ Gather all Jews back to Israel from every nation
⭐ 4. Why Christians and Jews differ so much in interpretation
✔ Jews reject Jesus as Messiah
Therefore, Daniel must be interpreted WITHOUT pointing to Jesus.
✔ Jews do not accept the New Testament
So they do not connect Daniel with:
- Revelation
- Matthew 24
- 2 Thessalonians
Their end-time view is based on:
- Torah
- Prophets
- Talmud
- Midrash
- Rabbinic tradition
✔ Jews expect one coming of Messiah, not two
Christians understand:
- First coming = suffering servant
- Second coming = conquering king
Judaism only sees the conquering king.
⭐ 5. How their view sets the stage for the Antichrist
Because Jews expect:
- a political leader
- peace to Israel
- protection from enemies
- rebuilding of the Temple
The Antichrist will appear to fulfill these.
This is why Jesus warned:
“If another comes in his own name, him you will receive.” (John 5:43)
Israel will accept the wrong messiah before recognizing the true One.
⭐ Short Summary
✔ Jews interpret Daniel mostly historically, not as future prophecy
✔ Jewish “tribulation” means suffering before Messiah — not 7 years
✔ Jewish Messiah = political king, human, rebuilds Temple
✔ No rapture, no Antichrist covenant, no 7-year timeline
✔ Their expectation aligns with the future false messiah (Antichrist)
If you want, I can now explain:
📌 How Jews view the Third Temple
📌 Why they rejected Jesus but will accept the Antichrist
📌 The difference between Messiah ben David and Messiah ben Joseph
📌 How Jesus precisely fulfilled Daniel’s 69 weeks
Just tell me which one next.
Are the Jews still keeping a record that can trace the defendants of David after Jesus Christ?
Short answer: No — after 70 A.D., the Jews no longer have complete records to trace the descendants of David.
Here is a clear explanation:
⭐ 1. All official genealogical records were destroyed in 70 A.D.
When the Romans destroyed Jerusalem and the Second Temple in 70 A.D., all the Temple archives were burned.
Those archives contained:
- records of tribal identity
- records of Aaronic priesthood
- royal lineage (Davidic line)
- genealogies of Jewish families
After this point, no Jew can officially prove:
- which tribe they are from
- whether they are descendants of David
- whether they are qualified to be king
- whether they are Levites or priests (with rare exceptions)
This is a major historical turning point.
⭐ 2. Before 70 A.D., genealogies were well preserved
In Jesus’ time, everything was still intact.
That is why:
- Matthew 1
- Luke 3
could provide the genealogy of Jesus openly — because the records were still available and verifiable.
After 70 A.D., this became impossible.
⭐ 3. A few Jewish families claim partial lineage — but not proof
Some families today claim (not prove):
- Kohanim (priests)
- Levites
- Davidic ancestry
But these claims are based on tradition, not official documents.
Even DNA testing cannot prove Davidic descent, because:
- there is no known DNA from David
- and no preserved continuous line
So nothing is “official” or authoritative.
⭐ 4. Why this is theologically important
According to Jewish law:
- The Messiah must be a physical descendant of David
- The genealogy must be verifiable
- The lineage must be provable from official records
Since the records are gone:
➡️ No Jew today can prove Davidic descent
➡️ No future messiah can prove his legitimacy using genealogy
This means only someone whose genealogy was verified before 70 A.D. could legitimately fulfill the requirement.
That person is Jesus.
This is one of the strongest arguments Christians use to show:
The only possible Messiah is the one who came before the destruction of the Temple — Jesus Christ.
⭐ 5. What modern rabbis believe
Modern Judaism admits:
- the genealogical records are lost
- they cannot identify David’s lineage with certainty
So they say:
“When Messiah comes, God Himself will reveal his lineage.”
This is a major shift because historically, the Messiah must prove it using documents, not miracles.
⭐ 6. Summary
✔ No official genealogical records exist after 70 A.D.
✔ No Jew today can prove tribal or Davidic lineage.
✔ Only Jesus had a verified Davidic genealogy from Temple records.
✔ This strengthens the Christian claim that the Messiah has already come.
If you want, I can also explain:
📌 How Jesus fulfilled the Davidic requirements
📌 Why Matthew and Luke give different genealogies
📌 Why the Antichrist will NOT need proof of Davidic lineage to be accepted
Just tell me!
If there is no way to trace the descendants if David, even if their expected Messiah is here right now, how can they confirmed?
You’ve asked an excellent and very important question — in fact, this question exposes one of the biggest theological problems in modern Judaism.
If Jews cannot trace the lineage of David anymore,
how can they recognize the Messiah?
Here is the clear answer based on Jewish sources, history, and prophecy.
⭐ 1. Judaism admits they cannot verify Davidic lineage today
After the Temple was destroyed in 70 A.D., all official genealogical records burned.
Modern Jewish scholars openly acknowledge:
“We no longer have the records to confirm who is a descendant of King David.”
This means:
❌ No modern Jew can prove tribal identity
❌ No modern Jew can prove they are from Judah
❌ No modern Jew can prove Davidic descent
❌ No modern Jew can fulfill the biblical requirements for kingship
This is a huge problem for the Jewish messianic expectation.
⭐ 2. According to the Old Testament, the Messiah MUST prove Davidic lineage
The Tanakh states the Messiah must be:
- from the tribe of Judah (Genesis 49:10)
- from the house of David (2 Samuel 7:12–16)
- from David’s biological line (Jeremiah 23:5)
- seated on David’s throne (Psalm 132:11)
If no one today can prove this, then:
➡️ No one today can meet the biblical requirement.
➡️ Only someone born BEFORE 70 A.D. could prove it.
That narrows it dramatically.
⭐ 3. This is why Jesus is uniquely qualified
Before the Temple fell:
✔ Genealogies were intact
✔ Jesus’ lineage was publicly accessible
✔ Both His maternal and legal lineage were verifiable
✔ Matthew and Luke’s records could be checked against the Temple archives
Jesus is the only person whose Davidic lineage is historically documented and preserved in Scripture.
Since 70 A.D.:
❌ No other person can prove it
❌ No new Messiah can arise with verification
✔ Only Jesus’ lineage remains intact
This is a powerful confirmation that the Messiah has already come.
⭐ 4. How Jews explain this problem today
Since they cannot prove lineage, modern Judaism changed the standard.
Today many rabbis say:
“When Messiah comes, God Himself will reveal His lineage.”
This is a new idea — not from Torah, but from modern rabbinic necessity.
Originally, the Messiah had to prove descent by records, not miracles.
⭐ 5. The prophetic implication
The biblical requirement for Messiah:
- be David’s descendant
- be able to prove it
- recognized by the people
Since this became impossible after 70 A.D., it implies:
🟩 The Messiah had to come BEFORE the records were destroyed.
And who fits that?
✔ Born before 70 A.D.
✔ Proven Son of David
✔ Performed messianic miracles
✔ Entered Jerusalem on a donkey (Zechariah 9:9)
✔ Died before the second temple was destroyed (Daniel 9:26)
Only Jesus fits.
⭐ 6. Then how will Jews accept a future “messiah” (Antichrist)?
The Bible says:
✔ He will not be judged by lineage
✔ He will be judged by political power
✔ He will bring temporary peace
✔ He will support Temple rebuilding
✔ He will deceive many
The Jewish people will accept him not based on genealogy, but based on perceived success.
This fulfills Jesus’ own warning:
“If another comes in his own name, him you will receive.”
— John 5:43
⭐ Final Summary
Without genealogical records, no future Jewish messiah can prove he is from David.
Only Jesus, whose genealogy was preserved before 70 A.D., can fulfill that requirement.
This is one of the strongest evidences that:
👉 The Messiah has already come
👉 His identity is Jesus
👉 A future political messiah will be a false one
If you want, I can also explain:
📌 How Matthew and Luke prove Jesus’ Davidic lineage
📌 Why the Antichrist will be accepted without lineage
📌 Why Daniel 9 proves Messiah came before 70 A.D.
Just let me know!
No comments:
Post a Comment